Stu sent this over, and it's so strong I thought it deserved a post. I'm watching the Costas/McGwire interview now, and will post something shortly. Here's Stu:
I read McGwire’s complete statement on your web site and wanted to pass along my perspective as someone who grew up in the 60’s and 70’s before cheating became commonplace and, to some degree, acceptable in sports. Looking at his statement there are a few questions I would love someone to ask him.
Feel free to use some of these if you want (no credit to me needed). I just want to see all of these guys called out on the carpet. As far as I’m concerned anyone who used PED’s cheated the game and cheated the fans. It still amazes me that players who chose not to use steroids during that era have never spoken out about the jobs and the income that they lost when they chose to do the right thing. Guys like McGwire, Pettite, ARod, etc. made a fortune of money after cheating. Money that they would have never made had they not cheated. Where is the punishment?
Stu from NJ
“After all this time, I want to come clean. I was not in a position to do that five years ago in my Congressional testimony, but now I feel an obligation to discuss this and to answer questions about it.”
You weren’t in “a position” to testify truthfully to the United States Congress? Perhaps now that it’s clear that you probably would never be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame that you realize that “coming clean” is your only opportunity to rehabilitate yourself with enough time remaining on your eligibility that you may someday make it?
“I used them on occasion throughout the nineties, including during the 1998 season.”
So will you be asking Mr. Selig to strike your name, or at least mark it with an asterisk, in the record books?
“Looking back, I wish I had never played during the steroid era.”
Oh. OK. So it is the fault of the “steroid era” and not you and your personal choices. Are you saying that everyone who played in that era used steroids? Hello, my I please speak with Mr. Ripken, Mr. Cal Ripken? (Are you saying that he is a fraud too?)
I’m sure people will wonder if I could have hit all those home runs had I never taken steroids.
Some people may wonder how many home runs Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and Roger Maris would have hit if they had take steroids. Perhaps they would have put up numbers so far out of reach that McGwire and Sosa in 1998 would have been insignificant.
Here’s a question for you (you can consult with Mr. Nice Guy, Andy Pettite – another one who just wanted to get back on the field with his teammates)
After you starting taking steroids in 1993 you signed contracts worth $56.5 Million (according to Cot’s Baseball Contracts). Now that you are admitting that you cheated, how much of the $56.5 Million will you be returning to the fans who paid higher ticket prices, etc. to support paying your contract.
Mark McGwire1b Oakland 1987-1997, St. Louis Cardinals 1997-2001
2 years/$30M (2002-03)
attendance bonus of $2/fan for each fan beyond 2.8 million
about 25% of $30M deferred at "reasonable" interest rate
2002-03 extension negotiated without an agent
retired 11/01, leaving 2002-03 extension unsigned
3 years/$28.5M (1998-2000), plus 2001 mutual option
i take issue with stu saying that he grew up watching baseball before "cheating" became commonplace. maybe it was before steroids became commonplace, but the use of amphetamines or "greenies" was incredibly widespread. the motivation to use these drugs was solely to gain a competitive advantage and they were absolutely performance enhancers. jim bouton wrote about these in 1969...and they had been around long before that.
we can't call one thing cheating and ignore the other simply because one of the two happens to have an impact on the sexiest stat in sports, while the other's impact might not be as readily visible.
in looking back, stu's argument is really full of holes from bottom to top...i don't understand what you found to be so strong as to warrant posting it here when there are other places where this discussion is being conducted that are meant for more serious discussion and not the more lighthearted stuff that i come to this site to read.
If you are visiting The Mets Police for the first time, welcome.
This blog aims to be a little different. We're less likely to complain about a pitching change than we are likely to complain about what the pitcher was wearing.
We're about Mets history and tradition. We'd like to see a Seaver statue at Citi Field. We'd like the black uniforms to go away. We'd like the team to always treat the fans with respect.
We're just regular old Mets fans like you who have migrated from the uppers to the Promenade where we were saddened when we found plexiglass. Finally, for all our complaining we just want the franchise to win the World Series (while nicely dressed).
The site is updated several times a day, usually morning, noon, and night (cliche but true) with other items as they come in.
Mets Police in no way claims to be news nor accurate, including anything to which we link. It's just a blog. Read the blog and/or take our advice at your own risk.
We strongly encourage everyone to support the New York Mets and their business partners, just don't wear a black jersey while doing so.
You get to pick 5 Mets. Who's your top 5? Doesn't this picture just make you happy? Click it and weigh in.
Most Popular (Jan 17)
New batting practice caps for 2010, Jason Bay t-shirts, McGwire shocks the world by announcing he took steroids, Beltrangate and more. Click the pic.
I asked fans for a list of Mets traditions, and we didn't come up with many. How is Banner Day any harder to have than a Mr. Met Dash? Either way it's people walking on dirt. Click the pic for the list.
Ticket office anecdotes
A collection of anecdotes related to Mets tickets, and my suggestion the Mets return 7 game packs and make Promenade Left the place to be. Click the pic.
1986 Tickertape Parade
Dan's photos from the 1986 tickertape parade. You know, 25 seasons ago when the Mets won?
My Mets man-date wish
Call me nutty, and I don't expect him to say yes or even know about this..but here's who I'd like to see a game with. Click the link and I'll tell you what we'll do.
Pix: trainer's room + clubhouse
Jimmy went on the season ticket holder's tour and took some photos including the Mets clubhouse and the infamous trainer's room. Click the pic.
The Mets Respond To Our Letter
Dan from Mets Police wrote the Mets a letter, Craig Marino the VP of Guest Experience called him back, and responded to many of our criticisms. A must read, click the pic.